If the villain is tight... what can he have in hand 1?

87,KQ,99+,9T,44,JT,KsJs,AsTs

those are "reasonable" hands he can have
you have 22.6% equity against this range
he also has air some % of the time but he'll never have air here often enough because he thinks you'll call

also, leaving a few cents behind is usually a sign of strength
I wouldn't go by that solely, but your equity is terrible regardless