Damn you never told me that haha. I have been playing for the past 3 years when I was in college. I don't get to play really anymore since I've graduated so this is pretty big for me. My arms ALWAYS get killed too so don't think it's just you! Plus I have a basketball game tomorrow so I can't go fullspeed tonight.
Not sure how stacked our team is because I've found that having the strongest/biggest people doesn't mean they'll be good at dodgeball. Would love to play your team haha.