|  | 
			
			
			
			
				 Anti-Capitalist Sentiment (with some morality)
				
					
						Let me start by saying I don't want this to be a poo-flinging thread or a rehash of old discussions.  I've just become inundated with anti-capitalism stuff lately and its been kind of driving me crazy so I wanted to talk to some smart left-minded folks which I am assuming is nearly everyone in this forum. 
 First, a few questions:
 
 1)  Is it morally wrong to pay someone 1 dollar an hour?  If yes, why?  If no, what is a set of conditions where it becomes wrong to pay someone 1 dollar an hour?
 
 2)  I am a gold miner.  I spend five million dollars to buy five potential mining sites (at one million dollars per site).  I am speculating that one of those sites will have 5.5 million dollars worth of gold thus my expected profit is half a million minus overhead.  I spend 200k on mining crews and equipment to speculate these mines, paying each of them 10 dollars an hour.  Four of them are dead ends, but luckily the fifth has a gold vein that I sell for 7 million.  I have profited 1.8 million dollars.  Am I wrong?
 
 3)  I am an entrepreneur.  I invest one million dollars in a restaurant.  I estimate that I will lose this investment about 80% of the time and 20% of the time I will have a successful restaurant that will repay the investment x5 in a few years.  Luckily, it is a hugely successful restaurant that nets 1.5 million dollars in the first year.  How much should I pay the bus-boy?  I paid him the minimum wage.  Am I wrong?
 
 4)  I was a big fan of Back to the Future 2 so I decided to invent the Hoverboard.  My Hoverboard company of which I am the primary share holder nets 500 million dollars a year, which I can spend or recapitalize at my discretion.  How much money is it ok for me to take for myself?
 
 5) Is profit wrong?  That one is obviously a tongue-in-cheek rhetorical, but seriously, what are some sets of conditions under which profit becomes wrong?  How much profit is too much, and why?
 |