Since my response is included in the 5 posts you're talking about, I'll respond here.

1.) A new poster that puts an expletive, disguised or otherwise, in the subject line of his very first post on FTR is basically suspect. If he wants respect, he should treat the forum with respect, and work on expanding his vocabulary.

2.) Hand is presented in OP without preamble and the vaguest of reads, which had to be expanded greatly later to justify the play. He did use the converer though, which is nice to see.

3.) None of the responses are that bad. I've seen much, much worse, have received much, much worse and expect to see much, much worse in future. In fact, my response is not insulting at all and says exactly why I don't like the play, succinctly.

4.) Don't expect FTRers to write more than a line or two responding to brand new posters until we know more about them and they have earned some respect.

5.) Just because your brother likes the play doesn't make it good.