I would go with James and Davis with the Jets D.
Foster is out this week so Davis should get most all the carries and hes a TD machine down around the goal line.
Lewis has always had good games against Clev, but with the way Balt has been playing and having no QB I would shy away from him.
My son has Lewis, Davis, Caddy and he's playing Lewis over Caddy this week, but mainly because of Caddy's injury.