That wasn't a redemption of the governor at all. What redeemed him? That he got the oxygen tanks or that he's projecting his daughter-related pain on the new little girl? And why was he just like "oh take my sweet shiny gun, I have this shitty revolver now", and why didn't he have that knife he used on the bathtub zombie for killing the old man or the pit zombies? And why am I over-analyzing a show that has demonstrated to give no fucks about making sense?