I misread the hand, I think you have to lay that down. He checked and then reraised all in, he was slow playin something big and realized he needed to protect it now. I'm assuming at $400NL you still get loose players sometimes so why isn't 56 possible? rainbow so he checked then realized one of you might have a set or two pair to suck out the boat with and on top of that the two over sets still beat you. I agree with nutsinho, easy fold.