Yeah. I think I've started to realize that when I do this, I shouldn't act like I'm continuation betting if I've been c-betting successfully.

I see you having two choices:
1) Bet the pot (or perhaps slightl ymore, like 1.25x the pot)and hope he doesn't believe you
2) Slowplay and try to get him to catch up.

Personally, I prefer option A, but sometimes I get a little reckless with my aggressiveness, so take that for what it's worth.