Fnord to be honest I think I psychologically gave up on the hand when the 2nd 5 hit the turn. If he had bet I would have been more inclined to put him on a weaker hand. With the speed of 4 tabling 6-max I couldn't really think this through like I've done since.

On the spur of the moment, I put him on a set on the flop or 2 pair min. I can't see a big draw possibly smooth-calling that flop reraise I made to 66E. As soon as the potential 2 pr/ set filled up on the turn I think I looked at the table and said BAD to myself. The only hand I can put him on w that flop action that I still beat (and even this is a stretch) is bottom 2. But even then : why the smooth-call?

Nothing made a whole lot of sense and on the spur of the moment it smelled too boaty.

Your point about the size of the river bet is well taken. But I think I'm trailing at least 60-70% of the time here.

BTW :

Game # 359003173 - Texas Hold'em No Limit EUR 0.50/1 - Table "Logrono"

Players(max 6):
Ravageur3 (EUR 140.10 in seat 1)
Ford_F (EUR 57.50 in seat 2)
Signor_H (EUR 61.30 in seat 3)
VILLAIN (EUR 180.75 in seat 4)
HERO (EUR 245.70 in seat 5)
ubersanta (EUR 108.90 in seat 6)

Dealer: Signor_H
Small Blind: VILLAIN (0.50)
Big Blind: HERO (1.00)

HERO was dealt : Ad-3h

ubersanta Call (1.00)
Ravageur3 Fold
Ford_F Fold
Signor_H Fold
VILLAIN Call (0.50)
HERO Check

Flop 5d - 2d - 4h YAY I HAVE 2ND NUTS!

VILLAIN Bet (2.75)
think I'll smooth call and pump an innocent turn w more ppl in hand!
HERO Call (2.75)
ubersanta Raise (15.00) OOH SOMEONE LIKES THEIR HAND!!!
VILLAIN Call (12.25)
HERO Raise (66.00) K. TIME TO TAKE THIS POT DAAOOOOWN.
ubersanta Fold
VILLAIN Call (53.75) WTF? WTF? SMOOTH-CALL WITH OUR STACKS? ohh.... he must be slowplaying his set vs. my apparent 2 pair! AWESOME!


Turn 5d - 2d - 4h - 5c

VILLAIN Check
HERO Check and GASPS AT LIKELY BOAT... VERY LIKELY THAT HERO CHECKED THE NOW-NUTS TO ME!!!

River 5d - 2d - 4h - 5c - 9h

VILLAIN All-In (111.00) OH GOD. THAT'S NOT EVEN 1/2 THE POT BUT HE WANTS TO MAKE IT LOOK LIKE SOME RIDICULOUS MISSED DRAW
HERO Fold HAHAHAHAHA I AM SUUUCH A SHARK. I MAKE SUUUUCH GOOD LAYDOWNS.

VILLAIN Payback (111.00)

VILLAIN shows: 6h - 8d (a pair of fives)

HERO VOMITS THEN DECIDES TO NEVER FOLD AGAIN AS LONG AS HE LIVES.