What more should I have done? (PL)

Flop a straight from BB, raise to max each time, guy goes all-in, should this be a call or fold at the end?

***** Hand History for Game 614169228 *****
Table Maverick (Real Money)
Seat 8 is the button
Total number of players : 6
Seat 5: yetiAllIn ( $0 )
Seat 7: liquid1109 ( $16.95 )
Seat 8: cigarmarco ( $153.35 )
Seat 9: mulespub ( $20.1 )
Seat 10: TheTaggart ( $24.85 )
Seat 1: SpookyDust ( $25 )
mulespub posts small blind [$0.25].
TheTaggart posts big blind [$0.5].
** Dealing down cards **
Dealt to TheTaggart [ 8h 9s ]
SpookyDust calls [$0.5].
liquid1109 folds.
cigarmarco: deuces
cigarmarco folds.
mulespub calls [$0.25].
TheTaggart checks.
** Dealing Flop ** [ Td, 7h, Js ]
mulespub bets [$0.75].
TheTaggart raises [$3.75].
SpookyDust folds.
mulespub calls [$3].
** Dealing Turn ** [ 6h ]
mulespub checks.
TheTaggart bets [$8.55].
mulespub is all-In.
TheTaggart calls [$7.3].
** Dealing River ** [ 3h ]
TheTaggart shows [ 8h, 9s ] a straight, seven to jack.
mulespub shows [ 4h, Th ] a flush, ten high.
mulespub wins $38.70 from the main pot with a flush, ten high.

CALL! You were the favorite when you put in your money. Don't confuse winning the pot with making the right play.

If you ever make this laydown, do yourself a favor and cash out all your online poker accounts to save yourself the grief. If you have to even think really hard about it, it's time to call it a night.