Printable View
http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/...20151111052225
Greetings again.
It's time for
https://www.businessforhome.org/wp-c...ote_Counts.jpg
Player (votes) || Voter [post in which they voted]
JKDS (3) || ong [22], rascal [29], BID [59]
boog (2) || JKDS [9], gabe [13]
gabe (1) || rilla [50]
rilla (1) || boog [24]
EOD1 is in ~8 hours.
EDIT: to correct ong's vote
I agree with the intent of this post. But, I think it's better stated that JKDS seems the most abnormal from his norm.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
I'm voting JKDS, post #22
Who cares that I'm abnormal. That doesn't make me a wolf, and having fun with boog doesn't either. Am I likely to start day1 like this as a wolf or as a villa? That's the question, and the answer is obv.
Rascal, show me a game where you didn't vote me early. Show me. You've had it out for me for several games now, and I don't think you've ever defended me.
And another thing. I've participated plenty. You know what's easy as fuck for a wolf to do? Come out of their hole and say I'm abnormal. Well make this man a detective. You're opening was "abnormal" for you too rascal. You started out more aggressive than typical of you. Ong is abnormal, he's "near certain" on day1 page1. Gabe is adamant in saying he ain't a villa. That's 4 "abnormals". Guess what, abnormal isn't role indicative. You need to do some actual work and expend some brain power to figure out if these ppl wold act thus was as a wold or villa.
As I think about it, I'm not so sure ong would say "near certain" day1. That's risky for a wolf, far riskier than I think ong would do.
Bid is bothering me too. He's posting very little, which isn't like him. I can see it as a wolf lurking strat, since he usually likes to be involved and doesn't give a fuck.
Smf seems villagery atm
Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
You guys are very sure so early on. I haven't seen anything from JKDS that makes him lean either way.Quote:
Originally Posted by lilrascal
So then why are you lynching Boog? Day 1 is a hugely underrated day for the village and, as I said before, your new style of playing loose and meaningless until you're forced to pull up hard near the tail end of the day isn't helping.
I at least tried to snap you out of your style today. I also helped juke Boog off of his usual opener and now I'm trying to get gabe to re-enter the thread after a lot of suspicious posts.
As gabe said,
I don't think JKDS or Boog will flip wolf. I don't want to lynch Rascal. I'm suspicious of Ong but I doubt I'm right about it. BID has been invisible. And I don't think much of anything about SMF or Hoopy.Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
lynch BID
He's been very terse so far.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
Transwolf is still going strong.Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
i like the idea of us getting to influence the game set up but it has definitely tightened up people's behavior
i'm voting for boog because jkds voted for him and the way jkds is acting, it makes sense that boog's chances of being a wolf werent completely random
When he was transwolfing, he had me lolling and was constantly keeping up an undercurrent of reassurances clueing to his villager role.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hoopy
rescind your jkds votes. hes my strongest villager so far. he doesnt need to post like this as a wolf
What? That's just not a sound approach to catching a wolf. Especially after he says he's going after Boog as a goof with little or no case.Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
I really like a gabe lynch now.
obv i havent participated too much so far but neither has anyone else....Quote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
we're on page 1 and day 1 is over in a single digit # of hours
the case is implied....Quote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
but this isnt vietnam...there are rules here
Quote:
Originally Posted by MadMojoMonkey
He literally says that he's doing it with little or no case and when he is campaigning for Boog, the only thing he's implying is that it's for a goof (as seen by his [serious] [/serious] asides).Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
I guess it comes down to how you interpret his attack on boog. He's dismissing it as lol it's d1 lynch boog, but I'm not buying it. He used language that, under the circumstances, can be considered ambiguous. It can have the effect of having people assume boog is > rand to be wolf (note gabe's recent posts), but if boog turns up villager, JKDS is protected from having to explain himself by the first rule of fight club. It's wolfy as hell. Furthermore, I think for JKDS to be villager, he's not only implying boog wolf, he implies JKDS special, and I don't think JKDS is ever that reckless as special.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hoopy
It's easily the most compelling case I can see for today's lynch. I mean the best you can do is drew for being "terse".
do you mean literally in the classical sense or the new definition?Quote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
Quote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
post 1 i think hes chastizing people for voting for him because it appears he has no case and is having funQuote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
post 2 hes kinda like "i know my case looks weak but hint hint hint"
i dont think a wolfjkds would fake this. this is the best piece we have to go on.
i also should add that i like voting for rilla, for the same type of reason that i think jkds wants to kill boog. so thats pretty funny that you (rilla) are antagonizing me currently
Literally, gabe.Quote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/...20151111052225
Greetings again.
It's time for
https://www.businessforhome.org/wp-c...ote_Counts.jpg
Player (votes) || Voter [post in which they voted]
JKDS (3) || ong [22], rascal [29], BID [59]
boog (2) || JKDS [9], gabe [13]
BID (1) || Hoopy [84]
gabe (1) || rilla [50]
rilla (1) || boog [24]
EOD1 is in ~4 hours.
You wish you were here!Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-OFdxUpG4CS...h%E1%BA%A1.jpg
...Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BYpYHZdCYAIvveF.jpgQuote:
Originally Posted by gabe
Even the fact that he's waffled back and forth on this speaks to why it's a bad idea to lynch Boog on the back of JKDSs positioning, gabe.
Also lol@bold, since you're now doing what you JKDS was doing to Boog. But I think there's stock in the thought that JKDS was doing it for the larf of it and I think you're doing it to try to protect yourself.Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
why wouldn't you just go after me on your own? Why, if you have the info you imply to have, wouldn't you act on that than to act on the shaky info you can't have any idea about from JKDS?
Why aren't you lynching me gabe if what you're implying is really the case?
cmon i obviously knew that post existed since i quoted it in the same post youre responding tooQuote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
i dont think jkds is saying "i did that for the lolz" in that post
i think hes referring to what people might think he is doing, and wanting to lynch him for it
gabe just did what I've been screaming at JKDS for.
Except gabe can't even pretend to not realise that it's a HUGE SPECIAL TELL because I've relentlessly pointed this out.
I can dig a gabe lynch too. gabe isn't that reckless either.
well i said earlier in the thread "boog or rilla are my targets" or somethingQuote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
an explanation was wanted for that earlier. now here i am, in the thread, giving it.
that's alot of questions from you. thats usually pretty wolfy. boog and rilla :shipit::shipit:
But then I deftly make him buttmad and he explains what he's doing:Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
This is still a continuation of him trying to find a day 1 play style where he survives and doesn't hurt his wolf game. That builds into him doing it as a larf.Quote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
Yeah, you said you were intent on focusing down on only me and Boog without expanding your focus too far and thus far you have not (except to say you suspect JKDS is villager with solid inside info).Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
This is the central reason why I think you're wolfy. You have no intention of exploring the village. You just want to focus on Boog and I (and your JKDS explanation).
Ong I missed your post. Now I see it. I know what you are thinking but I disagree
Rilla, I'm exploring now. You are here watching it happen
Quote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
Quote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
I like this series of posts.Quote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
Rescind
Quote:
Originally Posted by Hoopy
But, it I'm wrong about liking JKDS more recent posts and he does turn out to be a wolf, then Hoopy could very well be his partner.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hoopy
I'm not feeling great about Gabe's posts atm, but I'm not wanting to lynch him for them today.
Lynch BID
I think's a better lynch candidate for today.
I'm going to see Star Wars, so I won't be around for EOD.
I'm playing the storm and I'm table big stack so I might not be too engaged as eod approaches.
I'm happy to park on JKDS. I'll be keeping an eye on progress, at least on breaks.
ong you are making a bad vote on jkds. count on it
I'm happier with my read on JKDS than a "fuck it lynch drew" d1.
Rescind rilla
Rilla sounds reasonable in his last few posts. gabe has not helped his case and is sounding wolfier with every post. It's pretty easy to hide behind the "I'm not allowed to speak about what I'm thinking" argument and gabe is laying that argument on thick. Lynch gabe
I've hoopy, SMF and BID somewhere in the middle with all other players leaning villager. Meh.
Why do you think JKDS is wolfier than gabe?Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
Noticing this hasn't been answered yet. gabe made some sort of connection without really explaining much. He's somehow given off the illusion of logic though.Quote:
Originally Posted by lilrascal
I think it's the fact he was trying to laugh it all off, while getting annoyed. He's rattled. gabe is at least relaxed.Quote:
Originally Posted by BooG690
idk, it's hard to believe a wolf would say what gabe did after the shit I've given JKDS for exactly that. Regardless of JKDS' alignment. I'm kinda confused with gabe right now.
Why are you confused
Do you people understand the implication...
Boog and rilla gg
I'm crushing my table so don't expect anything exciting from me.
If this were between boog and rilla, I'd probably go rilla because I trust gabe more than JKDS.
But so long as JKDS is on the block, I'm staying put.
Oh, I fully understand the implication.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yUafzOXHPE
Gabe thinks JKDS is a lock villager? Why aren't you interested in disabusing him of this belief?Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/...20151111052225
Greetings again.
It's time for
https://www.businessforhome.org/wp-c...ote_Counts.jpg
Player (votes) || Voter [post in which they voted]
boog (2) || JKDS [9], gabe [13]
BID (2) || Hoopy [84], rascal [108]
gabe (2) || rilla [50], boog [113]
JKDS (2) || ong [22], BID [59]
no vote (1) || SMF
EOD1 is in ~30 minutes.
Rescind gabe, lynch JKDS
Well you've made your bed
Hrm, why the self pres instead of trying to move me off my less than random suspicion? It's not like I have any knowledge of whether I guessed correctly.
Maybe you is wolfing
It's hard to argue my case when you haven't really made a case against me. I still like a gabe lynch, fwiw.Quote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
Because I'm busy?Quote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
gabe says you're a wolf rilla. I'm not sure why you're concerned about why I'm not arguing with gabe about his alleged jkds lock villa read. You should be concerned about why he thinks you're a wolf. Why aren't you trying to convince him he's wrong? Or convince us he's wrong? Why, if you know he's wrong, would you have a problem with me not giving his jkds read any serious consideration?
What? I think gabe is the best lynch, meaning I think he's a high likelyhood to be a wolf. It kind of explains itself why I don't think he's onto anything.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
And his entire case on me is, apparently, 1) Early Boog-Rilla interaction implicates 1 wolf between the two of them. 2) He implies he knows my role.
I don't have to do anything to expose his wrongheaded thinking. It's clear as day.
Ok let me tell you where I'm at rilla.
I'm either lynching JKDS or you.
I'll let you decide.
I miss the good old days when villagers actually tried to win.
Weren't you suspcious of me? Is this aimed at me?Quote:
Originally Posted by a500lbgorilla
http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/...20151111052225
Greetings again.
Player (votes) || Voter [post in which they voted]
JKDS (3) || ong [22], BID [59], boog [122]
BID (2) || Hoopy [84], rascal [108]
boog (2) || JKDS [9], gabe [13]
gabe (1) || rilla [50]
no vote (1) || SMF
Oh my. It looks like JKDS is getting lynched.
Stay tuned for the flip.
Night will last 24 hours.
D2 will begin on Monday at 10:00 PM GMT.
Oh yeah, and JKDS's role PM said he was a VV.
Spoiler:...
but that was a lie
Anonymous PM:
So... what does that reveal mean?
Response:
:eh?:
What reveal?
:mischief:
I meant to hint that JKDS was a villager, but not vanilla.
I did not do a very good job of hinting.
I think it would give the wolves an (additional) information edge that I didn't account for when designing the game to leave my mistake as-is.
Please accept my apologies.
Just to be perfectly clear:
JKDS was lynched on D1.
As far as JKDS knew, he died as a Vanilla Villager.
The nuances to his role were unknown to him and will not come to pass in this game.
YES, you all know your alignment. NO, you may not know the full extent of your role.
Hey, gabe, I was wondering if ...
https://49.media.tumblr.com/f14940e8...s4wro1_500.gif
gabe has been brutally murderfied to deadness.
He was just scheduled for his robot eyes transplant, too.
He wont be getting that +1 to sight bonus that Toriel promised him.
Spoiler:gabe was a Village Seer
http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/...20151111052225
What's a game without a little unexpected death and destruction?
Haha.
lol.
*beep beep*
Who's next?
Can you solve the riddles to outwit your opponents?
Which team will win this battle of wits?
Stay tuned for the exciting D2 showdown!
Thread is now open.
D2 ends Wednesday, January 6 at 10:00 PM GMT.
Well this is shit.
Yeah it's pretty clear what today's play is.Quote:
Originally Posted by gabe
lynch rilla
Indeed it is.Quote:
Originally Posted by OngBonga
You were very sure that JKDS was a wolf ong, what are your thoughts on him flipping village?
Or more precisely how have your thoughts changed?
Interesting post about BooG. Both gabe and JKDS had him as suspicious which given the flips makes him worth looking at carefully.Quote:
Originally Posted by JKDS
I was right in that he was insincire. He thought he was vanilla, so he had no reason to suspect boog. It was a reaction test, but it had the effect of causing me to not trust him. I'm not gonna beat myself up for misreading JKDS here. He wasnt being honest, and I picked up on that.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hoopy
My other thoughts haven't changed. I felt rilla was iffy yesterday, he looks a dead cert now.
Important to note... gabe's wolf read on rilla is only a special tell to a wolf team with rilla in it.
rilla is a dead cert.
Scanning through rilla's posts, his focus is largely on boog, gabe, me and jkds. I can see 3/4 villagers here and I'm not sure rilla would be pushing at what's likely his only buddy on d1, so boog looks good to me also.
rascal tried to slam the brakes on the jkds wagon when I doubt wolves would, I think he's very likely villager.
I got rilla as wolf, with boog and rascal as villagers.
I agree with you about Boog being suspicious, especially with Boog voting both gabe and JKDS.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hoopy
I'm also a bit suspicious of Ong because I fake peeked Ong villa and I didn't get NK'd for it. It makes me think the wolves were certain that I wasn't seer.
I'm suspicious because you didn't get nommed? Seriously?
Isn't it obvious why gabe got nommed? Because rilla is a wolf who knew gabe was right about rilla being a wolf and thus concluded that gabe is in a priviledged position and is there special.
If I'm a wolf, I don't nom gabe (unless I'm wolf with rilla), because I'd know gabe is wrong about rilla, and thus not in a priviledged position, and thus probably not a juicy special.
gabe nom confirms that the wolves believed him.
It looks to me like they were certain gabe was special.Quote:
Originally Posted by lilrascal
Now why would they think that?
Do you think I'm that bad at this game where I'd nom gabe? I'm never nomming gabe there, ever. I'm actually surprised the wolves killed gabe, with him looking suspicious and all.Quote:
Originally Posted by Hoopy
I only jumped ship to JKDS out of self-preservation. If I were to do it over again, I wouldn't change my votes on D1 at all. Gabe was playing suspiciously and JKDS was the better lynch of the BID/JKDS imo. Also, with my vote parked on gabe and him being the bandwagon I openly supported, do you really think I nom him as a wolf there? I don't. That's suicide.Quote:
Originally Posted by lilrascal
Hoopy, why ignore gabe's suspicions of rilla? BID, SMF, some input/effort would be nice.
I'll be the first to admit that I'm not particularly interested this game. I think it's mainly due to some sort of holiday hangover, idk.
I'm liking ong this game and think we should follow gabe's lead.
lynch rilla
boog looks good to after his #148 post
What was suspicious of gabe's play on d1?Quote:
Originally Posted by BooG690