Yeah, I think that river bet is really awful from a metagame perspective if you're up against a regular, but I guess you agree and you had a good reason for making it.

It's logical that you won Hand 2 because it sounds like this guy was aggressive enough to make a bluff-raise. Also, his line just doesn't make any sense unless he turned a boat, and what hands would he re-raise you preflop with that would make a full house on the turn? If he just has Ax or a flopped flush I don't think he's checking the turn ever. The way you're asking the question makes it sound like a trick question though so you probably won Hand 1.