I really don't agree with clicking it back on this flop (with the intention of calling a shove), and taking back the initiative in this hand.

If what marshall is saying is true, and that redargoe is capable of c/r this flop with any 2 (which I think is likely the case on this board), I think that makes clicking it back even worse. We have a really strong hand, in position, so we should let him spew to us if he's capable of having air here.

I agree that taking this passive line (instead of having the initiative) gives us a headache and a hard decision, but sometimes the lines that give hero the hardest decisions are also the most +EV lines.

Taking over the initiative anywhere in this hand is stacking yourself when he has better (unless he's capable of felting AQ or some draw on turn? is that possible?) and letting him off easy when he has worse, IMO.