okay i'm guessing quite a few players will have a very similar graph to mine here. I've had this sort of trend for a long long time.

I think redline often is also a correlation of how many tables you play. For instance this graph is 6 tabling.

I'm a long term winner somewhere around 3ptBB/100 up to and including 200NL. I'm obv not a great player, but I seem to be winning. I never play unless there's fish at the table, preferably two. Also I generally ensure the fish are to my right. Because I'm mostly focusing on fish I'm forced to be far more on the value side of post flop play, including some thinner stuff like 2nd pairs obv but it means I'm forced to give up a TON of pots even to small bets because I think pure bluffing a ton esp against fish is terrible.

OOP i have a tendency to cbet most flops that I'm supposed to cbet, but then giving up near 100% UNLESS i have a hand or 8+ outs - this also leads to losing a ton of non-showdown spots.

i'd be interested in knowing the most simple things a players can do for non-sd spots. Playing super nitty or a ton of bluffing is not what i'm looking for.