Just browsing the 350 names left...
For:
Aaron Gordon (obv)
Andrew Brokos (Foucault from 2p2 and occasional posts here)
Matt Matros (2p2'er, read his book when I first started playing)
Hevad Khan (he's really good at basketball)
Tiffany Michelle (hot)
Maya Geller-Antonius (not as hot as her husband, but whatever)
Tommy Le (sick drummer)
Against:
Phil Hellmuth (obv)
David Benefield (raptor on 2p2, seems douchey)
Mark Vos (pro on FTP and he shortstacks, lol)
Jon "Pearljammer" Turner (he's a ginger)