Table had been going batshit insane for the last 5 minutes, so figured I'd jump in. And I got all I could have hoped for. So why does it not feel right?

Ignoring my occasionally wrong gut, what do you guys do?

PokerStars No-Limit Hold'em, $0.25 BB (9 handed) Hand History Converter Tool from FlopTurnRiver.com (Format: FlopTurnRiver)

MP2 ($34.40)
MP3 ($18.75)
CO ($90.50)
Button ($31.60)
SB ($9.75)
BB ($24.95)
UTG ($18.10)
Hero ($36.85)
MP1 ($7.70)

Preflop: Hero is UTG+1 with 3, 4.
1 fold, Hero calls $0.25, 2 folds, MP3 calls $0.25, CO raises to $0.75, Button calls $0.75, SB calls $0.65, BB calls $0.50, Hero calls $0.50, MP3 calls $0.50.

Flop: ($4.50) A, 2, 2 (6 players)
SB checks, BB checks, Hero checks, MP3 checks, CO checks, Button checks.

Turn: ($4.50) 5 (6 players)
SB bets $0.75, BB raises to $3, Hero...