Select Page
Poker Forum
Over 1,292,000 Posts!
Poker ForumFTR Feedback and Announcements

Restricting replies on the Bad Beats Board

Results 1 to 35 of 35
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    3,548
    Location
    Putney, UK; Full Tilt,Mansion; $50 NL and PL; $13 and $16 SNGs at Stars

    Default Restricting replies on the Bad Beats Board

    There's going to be a thread about it at some point, so I might as well start it...

    Just because some bad-tempered regulars got into as fight on the Bad Beats forum doesn't, IMHO, mean it should be closed. To be honest if someone DOES post a HH there which actually demonstrates bad play rather than bad luck then it's a GOOD thing if they get it pointed out to them.

    Seriously, though, I think it sets a bad precedent. Instead of making people behave it negates their responsibility to be good virtual citizens. What happens next time there's a fight on the NL strats forum? Or, heaven forbid, on the community, where Licence To Be A Dick is granted as a condition of posting there?

    When I post a bad beat I like getting comments or condolences. In fact, weak as it shows I am, I kind of crave such things - I doubt there's a single player on FTR who hasn't felt at one time or another that they MUST be playing badly when they get sucked out on time after time. The hard-nosed dudes who think there's no point to the bad beat board don't agree with this, I know, but lots of people do.

    Finally, I started a thread ("$100NL") on the bad beat board where I was actively looking for responses, admittedly for purely selfish reasons. Now no-one can reply!

    Anyway, I don 't think it's a terrible state of affairs or a catastrophe or an abuse of power (far from it - Xianti is one of the best moderators I've come across, and I say this as having been a pro mod myself in the past), but I just don't think it's the best course of action.
  2. #2
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    3,548
    Location
    Putney, UK; Full Tilt,Mansion; $50 NL and PL; $13 and $16 SNGs at Stars
    p.s Xianti, if you think this is better discussed off board, do PM me if you like - I'd be happy to discuss my thoughts on to one if you think it could be worth it.
  3. #3
    swiggidy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    7,876
    Location
    Waiting in the shadows ...
    Did they ban posts in the bad beat forum? That is totally gay.

    WTF, one person freaks out and leaves FTR thus changes must be made? This place is going into the shitter.

    If people can't control their emotions I say, good day sir.
    (\__/)
    (='.'=)
    (")_(")
  4. #4
    given the only value of the BB forum is that they don't end up elsewhere, this seems very +EV. NH
  5. #5
    gabe's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Posts
    13,804
    Location
    trying to live
    Quote Originally Posted by drmcboy
    given the only value of the BB forum is that they don't end up elsewhere
    i agree with this, but BB forum can be fun and it sucks that ONE PERSON had to ruin it
  6. #6
    gg 'fuck joker' thread
  7. #7
    let's re name the community the community bad beat forum, two birds, one stone.
  8. #8
    swiggidy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    7,876
    Location
    Waiting in the shadows ...
    Quote Originally Posted by drmcboy
    let's re name the community the community bad beat forum, two birds, one stone.
    Thus no relpies in the community either...

    Did I read between the lines properly?
    (\__/)
    (='.'=)
    (")_(")
  9. #9
    Bunch of fuckin' crybabys need their pat's on the back. Get a backbone. A couple of people get a little too upset and you are making wholesale changes?? Let the mods do what they are supposed to and delete or edit the over the line stuff. This is getting out of hand. Stop banning people, stop striking people and just edit the posts. People will get tired of their posts being edited and stop if it never makes it to the boards, problem solved. Having someone re-register, and make a thousand names up is worse than just editing his thread that you banned them for in the first post. Use your moderaters and stop the shit. People have gone over the line many times but I would rather have DoGGZ and the others here. Now Lambchop is 1 strike away because of two or three threads. Your losing your base of great talent because of things in the community and bad beat forum. Ya they may have been out of line but who the fuck hasn't been at least once in a while. I don't like losing these guys because of their contribution in other forums. Sure they will piss me and others off once in a while but one future thread from these guys can maybe save me hundreds in the next session.
  10. #10
    Good riddance... quit bitching and play poker.
    TheXianti: (Triptanes) why are you not a thinking person?
  11. #11
    that wasn't where I was going, it's just one place to put all the nonsense.
  12. #12
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Posts
    1,043
    Location
    Drinking your milkshake.
    Seems a shame we have to ban replies, just because a few people insist upon acting like children.
  13. #13
    bode's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Posts
    8,043
    Location
    slow motion
    this is obv. gay. let lambchop cry and leave, but leave the rest how it was.
    eeevees are not monies yet...they are like baby monies.
  14. #14
    Quote Originally Posted by DaNutsInYoEye
    Good riddance... quit bitching and play poker.
    QFT

    People who bitch about beats are totally missing the point of poker.
    It's not what's inside that counts. Have you seen what's inside?
    Internal organs. And they're getting uglier by the minute.
  15. #15
    gabe's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Posts
    13,804
    Location
    trying to live
    Quote Originally Posted by Trainer_jyms
    eople have gone over the line many times but I would rather have DoGGZ and the others here. Now Lambchop is 1 strike away because of two or three threads. Your losing your base of great talent because of things in the community and bad beat forum. Ya they may have been out of line but who the fuck hasn't been at least once in a while. I don't like losing these guys because of their contribution in other forums. Sure they will piss me and others off once in a while but one future thread from these guys can maybe save me hundreds in the next session.
    what did lambchop and doggz contribute?
  16. #16
    Xianti's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Posts
    9,246
    Location
    facebook.com/mediacookery
    This is a trial and it may go back to normal. At the very least, the hiatus might help cool down some would-be repliers.

    Feedback is welcome and always considered. But please keep your statements civil.


    Thank you.
  17. #17
    wtf this is gay as hell I want to post more in my FuckJoker thread.
  18. #18
    Lukie's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Posts
    10,758
    Location
    Never read any stickies or announcements
    Xianti,

    Why did you close the forum down? I'm just curious. You never closed down the commune, despite there being many similar occurances in that forum (and many others, I might add).

    I think it's a bad idea, by the way. Lock the thread, give out strikes/bannings, as needed, but close down an entire forum? Bad move, IMO.
  19. #19
    swiggidy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    7,876
    Location
    Waiting in the shadows ...
    Quote Originally Posted by ilikeaces86
    wtf this is gay as hell I want to post more in my FuckJoker thread.
    Aren't you a mod?

    Quote Originally Posted by gabe
    what did lambchop ... contribute?
    I was quietly wondering this. I don't know him and have no vested interest and secluded myself to the Sng and MTT forums for the last year. But I havn't learned much from him.
    (\__/)
    (='.'=)
    (")_(")
  20. #20
    ALLOW REPLIES IMO
    LETS GO CLIPPERS!!
  21. #21
    Unlock Bad Beat forum. FuckJoker must live on.
  22. #22
    Quote Originally Posted by ilikeaces86
    Unlock Bad Beat forum. FuckJoker must live on.
  23. #23
    thenonsequitur's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    1,311
    Location
    Location: Location
    I've been an FTR member for almost 2 years, and never even noticed the bad beats forum until the whole lambchop fiasco. I'm not sure how I missed it. But now that I know it's there, my opinion on it is that locking replies just doesn't make sense.
  24. #24
    Renton's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Posts
    8,863
    Location
    a little town called none of your goddamn business
    Quote Originally Posted by midas06
    Quote Originally Posted by ilikeaces86
    Unlock Bad Beat forum. FuckJoker must live on.
  25. #25
    Quote Originally Posted by ilikeaces86
    Unlock Bad Beat forum. FuckJoker must live on.
  26. #26
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    3,548
    Location
    Putney, UK; Full Tilt,Mansion; $50 NL and PL; $13 and $16 SNGs at Stars
    Quote Originally Posted by Rondavu
    Quote Originally Posted by DaNutsInYoEye
    Good riddance... quit bitching and play poker.
    QFT

    People who bitch about beats are totally missing the point of poker.

    And people who think posting bad beats is "bitching" are missing the point of the Bad Beats forum. Rondavu, you're more perceptive than most, this surprises me.

    SOME people post on the bad beats forum because they're angry and feel somehow "conned" out of their money. Rondavu is right about them. Most people, however, post bad beats for other reasons, namely:

    1. For consolation
    2. For amusement
    3. As a kind of buffer, a way of calming down and sharing your pain rather than letting yourself get angry
    4. the act of posting itself makes the poster realise hey, that's poker, it's not a conspiracy or anything worth sweating over

    The posts that shouldn't appear on the BB forum are the ones where a) they're not bad beats (losing a 70/30 shot isn't a bad beat guys), b) OMG RIGGED 4 REALZ posts, and c) posts that require discussion. But Aces' Fuck Joker thread is the perfect illustration of how bad beats aren't choosy about who they screw over, and even to someone like me who's played a fair bit and understands perfectly how probability etc work, it's genuinely reassuring seeing these things. And damn, they can be funny.
  27. #27
    I actually enjoy responding to threads in there.
  28. #28

    Default Re: Restricting replies on the Bad Beats Board

    Quote Originally Posted by Xianti
    Oh, yeah... and also...

    QFT!
  29. #29
    Locking down the bad beat forum is stupid. People post there to get some sympathy for their bad beats. Locking it down won't accomplish anything other than creating a huge mess of replies as new topics. Bad idea in my opinion.
  30. #30
    thenonsequitur's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2004
    Posts
    1,311
    Location
    Location: Location
    Quote Originally Posted by djzcko
    mess of replies as new topics
    This is something I can definitely foresee happening if the bad beats forum remains locked.
  31. #31
    Greedo017's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Posts
    2,284
    Location
    wearing the honors of honor and whatnot
    one crybaby should not determine something like this. we have a system for dealing with bad posts/posters. we need to change the system so that it is adequate for the bad beats section, not the other way around.
    i betcha that i got something you ain't got, that's called courage, it don't come from no liquor bottle, it ain't scotch
  32. #32
    Might as well delete the whole forum if there are no replies imho.
    She looked at me and said youz a baby right?
    I told her, I'm 18 and live a crazy life
    Plus I'll tell you what the 80's like
    And I know what ladies like
  33. #33
    Xianti's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Posts
    9,246
    Location
    facebook.com/mediacookery
    Okay. Your opinions have been heard. It's opened again for replies.
  34. #34
    Quote Originally Posted by Xianti
    Okay. Your opinions have been heard. It's opened again for replies.
    Great. I'd never read it before because I thought i wouldn't be interested in reading about other people's bad beats but some of the posts are quite entertaining so i will read more when i want a laugh. Now that reminds me, let me tell you about the time that my AA got cracked by QQ and Q5 calling my (large) raise and then the flop was AKT with a J on the turn.............................................. .................................................. .........................etc, etc. LOL
  35. #35
    AAnalTTorture Guest
    I bad beat your mom last night and she liked it

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •