|
|
 Originally Posted by digitaldoc
As with any poker hand, the answer is "depends".
I really like to pick out two or three people I want to get my chips from at the table. I make my selections taking into consideration, my position verses them, stack sizes and their degree of apparent poker expertise. My honest guess, not knowing the other players at the table, soupie is not going to be the one I want to get chips from.
Here's why I fold this hand.
1.) I can easily steal a big blind back from one of my targets.
2.) I am not willing to swap chip stacks with a known very aggressive late stage player. He is far more dangerous with a bigger stack. If he survives the hand, he'll keep putting massive pressure on you till one of you is out or you move tables.
3.) You only have one way to win this hand, and that is showing down the best hand which is a pure coin flip against any two.
4.) I'm looking to make a call with a hand that I think is still a dominating hand or at least a 60/40 against a smaller stack. That I'm calling with pocket 5's and up.
I don't necessarily disagree with any of this. I honestly think that you can't really screw up too bad here - the edge in folding or calling is so small that it is insignificant in the long run. But just for kicks I'm going to provide a counterargument:
1) Actually, I can't steal that easily anymore. I have an M somewhere below 10, as do the majority of the players remaining. So we are now at the stage of a tourney where people just pick a hand and go with it. Yes, I still have fold equity, but the chances that I will now get called on one of my pushes is much higher now.
2) Although soupie is going to be a major problem with even more chips, I would much rather have him out than have him remain and constantly applying pressure in situations where I was hoping to do so but now can't since he steals my first in opportunities. The reward of taking his chips and increasing my stack outweighs the risk in letting him stay and letting him steal even more of my opportunities.
3) I might only have one way to win this hand, but my odds to do so are 50/50 and I am getting pot odds to do so. It's almost never a bad thing to make an even super small +EV move against the best players at the table (since you are rarely going to be able to make a huge +EV call against them).
4) Again agaisnt a dominant player, making a 51/49 play is not such a bad thing. If you win, you are now the dominant player at the table. If you lose, you just go into ABC shortstack playing.
|