Select Page
Poker Forum
Over 1,292,000 Posts!
Poker ForumFTR Community

Investing in gold anyone familiar?

Results 1 to 21 of 21
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    1,189
    Location
    Live Poker Room

    Default Investing in gold anyone familiar?

    Hi just wondering if anyone knows anything about investing in gold?

    Any good articles / books to read on the subject?

    I've seen bullionvault and while the idea of being able to buy and sell so easily seems attractive the idea that I don't have the bullion in my hand puts me off, the aspect of having some worth in material that I own and can touch and feel is kind of appealing.

    I'm talking very small scale, buying the odd ounce now and again maybe, so far from the small bit of time I've spent looking into this it seems that my best bet would be Krugerrands, Canadian Maple Leafs, or British Soverigns,

    Does that sound about right?

    Any one that has experience and can point out some pitfalls and reduce the learning curve that would be great.

    Thanks!
  2. #2
    Investing requires bankroll management. You're screwed!
  3. #3
    I haven't followed this much, but speculators are likely creating a gold bubble. So if you do buy it, keep up to date on the bubble so you can sell it in time

    Commodities are generally good mild investments though due to scarcity and inflation. Put they're small beans, so you don't find speculators going long term with them since more money can be made in playing the waves. For the general investor, some gold in portfolio is good.

    I couldn't say exactly what to look for WRT gold in the markets though. If I had to guess, speculators have been going after gold because the Fed is going to do what it can to cease deflation, and at some point in the nearish future, the econ is going to have to see pretty strong inflation. My guess is they're trying to get in lo so they can make the profits from hi while some are specifically trying to create a bubble since there are really no better ways to game the system than to accurately speculate on boom/busts
  4. #4
    bjsaust's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    6,347
    Location
    Ballarat, Australia
    Yeah, like wuffy I havn't been following, but my impression was that gold is pretty inflated atm as a lot of people converted from shares into gold during the gfc.
    Just dipping my toes back in.
  5. #5
    I am quite knowledgeable on this subject.

    Gold (and all precious metals) are measured in troy ounces in North America. 1 troy oz = 31.103 grams. In Europe kilograms is a common measure/size for precious metals.

    Spot price is the current price of the metal. Spot is a guideline. Generally coin/bullion dealers will sell gold coins at a small premium (5-20% depending on size of the coin, amount purchased, etc) and buy gold back anywhere from spot -10% to spot +10%.

    Bullion means that the item's worth is based on it's metal content/intrinsic worth. This is in contrast to any other value a coin/bar/etc may have, such as collectible value. An example would be a special edition/colorized/hologramed/etc 1oz gold coin from the Royal Canadian Mint. Typically these will sell (retail) for 50-100% above the bullion value- that is, the value of the metal content in and of itself.


    Investing in gold: there's a few options-

    1) Buying Physical metal. Look for recognized coins/bars that are .999 fines (such as Canadian maples) or 22k (91.7%, such as American gold eagles, sovereigns and South African Krugerands). I'd generally stick with 1oz bars/coins if you can afford it, as the premiums get quite high the smaller you go if you are buying fractionals (1/2oz, 1/4oz, 1/10th oz, even 1/20th oz).

    Liquidity is key, don't get some 5oz or larger bar (unless you are a rich mofo and are planning on owning say 100oz+ of gold) because when it comes time to sell it will be difficult to unload.

    There's also various government minted commemorative gold coins, that are lesser known (this less liquid) but can be had for lower or no premium above the spot price of gold. For example, the Royal Canadian Mint issued a number of 22k gold "collector" coins in the 1980's and 90's. They are 16.965g of 22k (91.7% gold), which works out to exactly 1/2oz of pure gold.

    2) Gold mining stocks. I don't know much about these, but they are often highly speculative penny stocks. Their prices fluctuate largely as a function of the current price of gold and how much the company estimates it will at some point in the future, pull out of the ground.

    3) ETF (Exchange Traded Fund). I don't know much about these either. But it is basically like buying a stock, where the companies performance tracks the price of gold (POG) in some way. I believe there are ways to leverage, such as ETFs where each $1 move in the POG results in a multiple ($2, $3 or more) move in the price up or down of the ETF.

    4) Unallocated pool account. This is basically like a bank account where your money is held in ounces of gold (or other commodity, usually precious metals) and is like an IOU for that amount of ounces. If the bank/company/etc holding your money in the pool account goes broke, so do you. These generally trade at very small margins. Something like +0.5% on the buy side, -0.5% on the sell side.

    5) Allocated pool account. This is similar to the last, except the company you've given your money to allocates you certain bars of gold (serial # and all) and stores it for you in their vault (for a monthly/yearly fee). You can opt to have your gold shipped to you for a fee as well.


    Miscellany/opinion:

    The commodities market (especially gold) is generally shat upon by traditional investment "gurus" because a) they aren't knowledgeable outside their fields and b) they don't make money when people buy gold or even commodities ETF accounts.

    Some people argue that gold/silver/commodities aren't really gaining value, but rather paper (fiat, unbacked) dollars are losing value. This is at least partially true.

    Historically gold does well in periods of inflation, war, economic uncertainty. It has also been a store of wealth for thousands of years.

    In my opinion, in the long run (40+ years), gold doesn't have as high of an ROI as stocks/index funds. However, there are periods (as mentioned above) where gold way out preforms the stock market. We are in one of those times right now.

    We aren't currently in a gold bubble, but I think there's a good chance that within 3-5 years we will see a real gold bubble. See link #3. We are just starting to see the first real (and positive) media attention for gold. We've been in the awareness phase for a while, probably just crossing into the mania phase around now.

    A huge sign of when the bubble has taken off will be mass tv commercials selling gold to consumers. Currently the trend is still most people selling "junk/unwanted" gold, often to those cash for gold places. It's when these people/consumers get back into buying gold as an investment that I will be looking for the exit, because the bubble will be going in full swing.

    Some reading material regarding the stock market/gold relationship:

    Gold Versus Paper: The Dow to Gold ratio - the aha! moment
    100 Year Dow Chart - John Lounsbury -- Seeking Alpha
    House Prices Will Fall Further: Graphs / Money Watch <- is about the housing market, but the prototypical bubble chart is very interesting
    Current Melt Value Of Coins - How Much Is Your Coin Worth? - site shows the value of old coins based on their precious metals content at the current spot prices

    Important- Finally, some pitfalls to avoid:

    - Never, ever, ever sell any gold to cash for gold tv commericals/gold kiosks in malls or anything of the sort. They will literally pay you 20-40 cents on the dollar.

    - Ebay (or other) auctions/sales touting "1 troy lb" of precious metal (usually silver). There's 28g per oz and 16oz in a lb. In the troy system there's 31g per troy oz, and 12 troy oz per lb. They will price auctions that look like a great deal for 16oz, because they will only be sending you 12oz.

    - Numismatic coins. I am a coin guy at heart, but the numismatic (coin collector) market is much more like baseball cards that it is like bullion. If you don't know how to properly evaluate a coin's grade/value, just stick with bullion. An example would be pre-1933 USA gold coins. A common date 1920's $20 gold coin contains 0.9765 oz of pure gold. But the price of the coin depends on condition. A damaged/bad condition coin might retail for spot +10%. One in immaculate condition might cost spot +1000%. There have been many news reports on people being burned by buying these types of coins because they didn't know what they were getting into.

    - Fakes on ebay/elsewhere. Stick to reputable dealers. High feedback ebay sellers are fine. Stay away from any Chinese/Asian based sellers. There has been a literal flood of fake coins/bars coming from there. Some are very high quality fakes. Buying a digital scale/using a ruler or caliper is highly recommended, as fake coins/bars will be underweight and/or oversized when they are made from the wrong metal.


    Long post but hopefully it will be informative. I'll be happy to answer any questions.
    Some days it feels like I've been standing forever, waiting for the bank teller to return so I can cash in all these Sklansky Bucks.
  6. #6
    gold and silver are going nuts. I get the sense that by this stage its usually too late and is near peaked, but if you feel like the world economy will get worse before it gets better then it might still be +ev to get some gold.

    What annoys me is, ive been saving for a gold ring for myself (pimp) and gold just keeps getting pricier
  7. #7
    BooG690's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Posts
    5,090
    Location
    I am Queens Blvd.
    KoRnholio pwnd this thread.

    Where are good places one can buy gold? I generally don't trust anything like this coming from the Internet, even reputable eBayers. I wants in on gold now!
    That's how winners play; we convince the other guy he's making all the right moves.
  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by mbiz View Post
    gold and silver are going nuts. I get the sense that by this stage its usually too late and is near peaked, but if you feel like the world economy will get worse before it gets better then it might still be +ev to get some gold.

    What annoys me is, ive been saving for a gold ring for myself (pimp) and gold just keeps getting pricier
    Honestly, I think silver is a better buy if you're willing to accept more risk for a better ROI. I suspect most of us are poker players are in that camp Silver generally takes the same path as gold, but it's also effected more by the economy as it's a big industrial metal as well.

    I still think both gold and silver are good long term buys right now.

    I picked up a nice old ring off ebay a year ago for just above the melt value. 18k with a square, flat onyx stone, made around the 1930s/40s. I don't think I could ever pay retail prices for gold jewelery again after having my eyes opened about gold bullion available for a few percent over the spot price.

    Pic of my ring:




    Quote Originally Posted by BooG690 View Post
    KoRnholio pwnd this thread.

    Where are good places one can buy gold? I generally don't trust anything like this coming from the Internet, even reputable eBayers. I wants in on gold now!
    Haha thanks I'm all about hobbies that can make money, so poker/coins/bullion is kinda my thing.

    You can try going locally. Try looking up coin or bullion shops on google maps. Kijiji also often has coin/bullion ads. Sometimes you'll even find indivduals (non-dealers) selling gold or silver for okay to decent prices.

    There's a number of solid online places to buy that are good if you're buying a decent amount (say 3oz+ of gold or 100oz+ of silver).

    I live in Canada, so my options are more limited. I've used APMEX, NWTM (Northwest Territorial Mint, based in Washington state I believe) and Kitco. APMEX recently upped their premiums on amounts of silver under 500oz so I don't think I will be buying from them again for the time being. APMEX definitely has the best selection of bullion. Kitco's shipping+insurance charge is quite high, almost misleading. I think they'd have decent prices for shipping within the USA though.

    If you want a big purchase, Tulving is by far the best bang for the buck. The website is garbage, the minimum order is 500oz of silver (not sure on the amount of gold, probably 5-10oz?) but the prices are by far the best. If they ever started shipping to Canada I'd be extremely happy.

    There's a few other sites, Gainesville, Provident Metals, probably many others that will have pretty similar prices. Doesn't hurt to shop around, take shipping/insurance/other charges into account.

    Some more random nuggets of wisdom/small rant:

    - Don't pay extra for bullion coins encased in plastic that are graded. This is a huge fad on ebay right now. People are buying and selling new, common bullion coins for huge premiums because some company has graded it perfect (MS70) or near perfect (MS68/69). It's honestly a joke.

    The Sheldon grading system (1-70) was created in the 1940's for use on mass produced coins minted for circulation. MS (mint state) 70 was always a theoretical/unacheiveable highest grade. Modern bullion coins are minted much more carefully and slowly than mass produced circulating coinage. So the reality is that they all come out nearly flawless anyways. Even I wouldn't be able to tell the difference between a true MS69 and 70 coin. So don't go out and pay more because it has a fancy label inside a plastic slab
    Some days it feels like I've been standing forever, waiting for the bank teller to return so I can cash in all these Sklansky Bucks.
  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    1,189
    Location
    Live Poker Room
    Thanks for the replies guys and thanks KoRnholio for the great advice, you've really consolidated alot of what I had been picking up and I'm yet to read the articles you posted which I'll do tonight and tomorrow so thanks very much, appreciate the time it must have taken you to type.

    Interesting what you said about the bubble not being just yet, despite the spot price being so high at the moment in absolute terms compared with previous prices, I remember reading on one of the sites I was on recently that previously when you compare prices with inflation, the relative value of gold has been higher than it is currently - so it makes sense that it's not quite as inflated as you might first think by simply looking at historic graphs.

    Also intersting what you said about the difference between rising gold value and lowering currency value.

    There is something really appealing about owning a precious metal that is more or less worth what I paid for it, 'worth it's weight in gold' if you like. Possesing your wealth yourself seems like a fairly liberating idea, instead of it being stored on some bank balance sheet somewhere.

    I'm going to buy my first ounce in a couple of months I think once Christmas is out of the way, in terms of buying in the UK - I was thinking of trying to find if there are any small arms of the companies that are part of the gold fixing cartel and buy from them. I would imagine you can't really get much more reputable than those guys, do you know if they sell to private small time investers? If they don't - if you were in the UK - what would you do to research the best place to buy from?
    Last edited by LuckySlevin; 11-25-2010 at 06:15 PM.
  10. #10
    You're welcome. TBH I wouldn't be too worried about buying a fake or anything as long as you're staying away from low feedback/chinese ebay sellers. I would invest in a digital scale with 0.01g accuracy though. These are readily available on ebay for under $15. As long as the gold coin is the right dimensions and weight, it is the right density, which is pretty much impossible to fake in 1oz and smaller sizes. The only malleable metal that is close to the same density of gold, is platinum.

    I don't know which companies would be best for a UK buyer. You could try asking at the kitco.com forums (https://www.kitcomm.com/index.php). I used to read their forums a lot, but it's mostly just people talking out of their ass, lots of trolls, etc.

    Also, gold (as well as the other PMs) has started pulling back after the recent run up. I'd recommend waiting a little bit to buy, a month or two perhaps. It'll give you some time to shop around as well.
    Some days it feels like I've been standing forever, waiting for the bank teller to return so I can cash in all these Sklansky Bucks.
  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    1,189
    Location
    Live Poker Room
    great thanks will do, thanks resident gold expert
  12. #12
    Ragnar4's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Posts
    3,184
    Location
    Billings, Montana
    maybe I'm retarded, but wouldn't you want the bubble to burst, *THEN* buy the gold?
    The Dunning–Kruger effect is a cognitive bias in which unskilled individuals suffer from illusory superiority, mistakenly rating their ability much higher than average. This bias is attributed to a metacognitive inability of the unskilled to recognize their mistakes
  13. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by Ragnar4 View Post
    maybe I'm retarded, but wouldn't you want the bubble to burst, *THEN* buy the gold?
    Not really. From what I have read and seen, the gold/precious metals market is a pretty small niche market most of the time. When it does gather a ton of media and then investor attention, it ends up getting way ahead of itself and bubbles hard. After it bursts, it then lies dormant (ie, ~0-5% ROI/year) for 15+ years because everyone has then jumped into completely different markets.

    Take a look at the Dow vs Gold blog link I posted and you'll see what I mean. They tend to take turns being the Bull and Bear markets. If you look at the current Dow/Nasdaq/etc charts, you'll see they've been pretty flat since the 2008 crash. Very bearish. Now look at any of the PM (precious metal) charts on kitco.com. They're all very Bullish.

    quick little edit- Think of markets as a poker analogy. It's profitable where the action is. Once the action is dried up, it means everyone has gone elsewhere in search of new profitable games/tables. Right now it's like the action in the dow/stock markets is currently dried up. Gold/PMs is the new action market.
    Last edited by KoRnholio; 11-28-2010 at 02:13 PM.
    Some days it feels like I've been standing forever, waiting for the bank teller to return so I can cash in all these Sklansky Bucks.
  14. #14
    Haven't read other responses but I will tell you it's not a good investment. Besides it's near the top and not the correct time to buy at all!
    "You start the game with a full pot o’ luck and an empty pot o’ experience...
    The object is to fill the pot of experience before you empty the pot of luck."

    Quote Originally Posted by XxStacksxX View Post
    Do you have testicles? If so, learn to bet like it
  15. #15
    Quote Originally Posted by HarleyGuy13 View Post
    Haven't read other responses but I will tell you it's not a good investment. Besides it's near the top and not the correct time to buy at all!
    We'll be at the top of a bubble when people with this attitude start buying gold.
    Some days it feels like I've been standing forever, waiting for the bank teller to return so I can cash in all these Sklansky Bucks.
  16. #16
    hahahahha
    Normski
  17. #17
    bjsaust's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    6,347
    Location
    Ballarat, Australia
    Quote Originally Posted by bjsaust View Post
    Yeah, like wuffy I havn't been following, but my impression was that gold is pretty inflated atm as a lot of people converted from shares into gold during the gfc.
    I'm glad I changed my mind and bought gold through my super fund (via BullionVault)
    Just dipping my toes back in.
  18. #18
    Is it still a good time to buy gold? Let's say the second great depression is actually coming...
  19. #19
    Fiat currency systems historically have a pretty short shelf-life (see History of Fiat Money. We're currently in about year 40 of the most recent purely fiat cycle. Compound that with inflation due to money printing/bailouts/etc and MASSIVE amounts of debt, and there is very likely a massive shit storm coming. It basically all leads to real assets and commodities going up in value relative to our paper money.

    I would also be very cautious about buying "gold" through ETFs/mutual funds/paper certificates/etc. All they are is an IOU from that company or fund. Virtually all of them only own a tiny percentage of the amount of gold they sell/loan out to investors. Essentially they are taking X ounces of gold, and selling pieces of paper to 100X people telling them they own that ounce of gold. Google fractional reserve banking for more info.
    Some days it feels like I've been standing forever, waiting for the bank teller to return so I can cash in all these Sklansky Bucks.
  20. #20
    Oops I didn't notice this response before, but YGPM.
  21. #21
    The gold one.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •