Polygamist Werewolf

[BooG690]

Imma call it with Luco, gabe's a villager.

gg guys.

Oh? So Hoopy and I are wolves by ourselves?

[BooG690]

Where's villager Rilla that wants to win this game?

[Luco]

I've been suspicious of boog all game

lynch boog

but then rilla basically takes Day 1 off, then is trusting a player that hasn't been here all game.

rescind

lynch rilla

You can't possibly believe this. Rilla doesn't sheep, ever.

If he agrees with me then he got there on his own

[Luco]

Where's villager Rilla that wants to win this game?

Appeal to emotion.

I smell panic.

[BooG690]

Appeal to emotion.

I smell panic.

Fuck emotion. It's meta. Villager Rilla doesn't flip so quickly from gabe to me (exactly what I said would happen) with no new information.

[JKDS]

VOTE COUNT?

Gabe (2): Boog, Hoopy
Boog (2): Luco, Rilla
Rilla (1): BID

~69 hours left in the day

No further extensions will be granted

[BooG690]

At least one wolf on my wagon. If not, game is lost with wolf wagon.

[OngBonga]

drew what the fuck are you doing voting for rilla.

monkey please don't vote for rilla.

drew should rescind so we can figure shit out here. There's two people now on two votes. We can eliminate possibilities but drew's vote on rilla looks so so bad right now to me.

[OngBonga]

Why is rilla so sure gabe is a villager?

[OngBonga]

Well we lynched a villager yesterday. So therefore it could be anyone

And since ong loooooooooves to bus. Is everyone legit ruled out as his partners therefore his clearance? Would be a bad way to lose. Good way to win. But bad way to lose. If ya feel me

This isn't about bussing. This is now about logicistics. Bear in mind that gabe has been on two votes now, I can only be a wolf with boog/hoopy. Or gabe/luco. They're the only two possible teams I can be in that couldn't just win right now. And I'm obviously not a wolf with gabe, I mean there's bussing and there's stupid hard bussing that loses the game. So the only viable team I can be on is boog/hoopy. And I've been on their case all game too. Only difference is that I've been pushing for gabe ahead of them, so I could at least accept that niugget of paranoia. But since wolves haven't won yet, we can eliminate certain teams.

More time needs to pass with boog at two votes before any solid conclusions can be drawn.

[OngBonga]

lol logicisitcs

[OngBonga]

gabe's posture today has been that of a wolf desperate to find a mislynch, rather than that of a villager worried about wolves nailing him. That should be abundantly clear. boog/hoopy should be confirmed wolf from his pov, if indeed he's a villager.

I'm not gonna hold my vote back while rilla picks up a sloppy vote.

lynch gabe

[BankItDrew]

drew what the fuck are you doing voting for rilla.

monkey please don't vote for rilla.

drew should rescind so we can figure shit out here. There's two people now on two votes. We can eliminate possibilities but drew's vote on rilla looks so so bad right now to me.

rescind
why does it look so bad to you? Why are you so worried? Are you and rilla wolves?

[OngBonga]

If me and rilla are wolves we can already win ffs

[OngBonga]

I mean I guess we could be waiting for aubrey.

Ok we could be wolves waiting for aubrey.

But let's see how long gabe sits here on three votes with no action.

[OngBonga]

rilla votes looks bad drew because I think you and rilla are both villagers.

[OngBonga]

rescind

Y'never know if you catch a wolf train in action. Maybe one in a million chance...

[OngBonga]

Aw.

lynch gabe

[BooG690]

Heh. That made me chuckle.

[BankItDrew]

If me and rilla are wolves we can already win ffs

This is probably true.

[BankItDrew]

Heh. That made me chuckle.

Chuckle at this!

lynch boog

[BooG690]

Chuckle at this!

lynch boog

One more villager vote on me and that's game, folks.

[OngBonga]

One more villager vote on me and that's game, folks.

Why is drew a villager from your pov again?

[BankItDrew]

Why is drew a villager from your pov again?

<3

ong for mvp

[OngBonga]

VOTE COUNT?

Gabe (2): Boog, Hoopy, ong
Boog (2): Luco, Rilla, BID

~69 hours left in the day

No further extensions will be granted

Updated

[BankItDrew]

BECAUSE BOOG KNOWS I'M A VILLAGER DURRRRRRR

[OngBonga]

It's 3-3,, not 2-2.

I so nearly ninja'd that then...

[BooG690]

Why is drew a villager from your pov again?

He wasn't until Rilla entered back into the picture. I'm 100% certain gabe is a wolf here. Rilla's vote for me after Luco's "gogogo Rilla" and bold for me (while saying he was 100% sure Luco and Gabe were wolves) with no additional information has me at > 87.5% Rilla/Rascal being wolf. Therefore, BID is likely village.

[BankItDrew]

It's 3-3,, not 2-2.

I so nearly ninja'd that then...

ninja'd?

[OngBonga]

ninja'd?

edited

[OngBonga]

I notice that gabe still isn't voting for boog, even though boog is confirmed wolf from his pretend villager pov.

[BankItDrew]

I notice that gabe still isn't voting for boog, even though boog is confirmed wolf from his pretend villager pov.

I noticed this too. The only thing tho is that they can't both be wolves because there would be a third wagon.

[OngBonga]

I noticed this too. The only thing tho is that they can't both be wolves because there would be a third wagon.

I'm not so sure about that.

[OngBonga]

I mean there nearly was a third wagon. Their votes are on standby.

[BankItDrew]

Day 2 ends in what? 16 hours? EST people are going to sleep soon.

I think there's a 10% change that gabe and boog are both wolves.

[JKDS]

VOTE COUNT

Gabe (3): Boog, Hoopy, Ong
Boog (3): Luco, Rilla, BID

~66 hrs left

[OngBonga]

#69 hours whenever JKDS last posted

Loads of time.

[OngBonga]

There. 66 hrs.

[BankItDrew]

The fuck? lol nm

[OngBonga]

Don't anyone vote for five mins or so. I'm just crunching some numbers to see what we can poe it to based on the current vote count.

[OngBonga]

gabe/luco boog/hoopy rilla/rascal drew/monkey ong/aubrey

VOTE COUNT

Gabe (3): Boog, Hoopy, Ong
Boog (3): Luco, Rilla, BID

GL+BH - cannot win
GL+RR - cannot win
GL+DM - can win by lynching boog
GL+OA - can win by lynching boog

BH+RR - cannot win
BH+DM - cannot win
BH+OA - cannot win

RR+DM - can win by either lynch
RR+OA - can win by either lynch

DM+OA - can win by either lynch

[OngBonga]

GL+BH - cannot win
GL+RR - cannot win

BH+RR - cannot win
BH+DM - cannot win
BH+OA - cannot win

These are the viable teams based on the current state of affairs. This is not taking anything into account other than the simple fact the wolves have not yet won. This also assume wolves have had enough time to synch, which might not be the case in boog's case.

It's a guide, but one that gets stronger with time.

[OngBonga]

GL+DM - can win by lynching boog

This is a very good eilimination. drew can only be a wolf with hoopy/boog, but drew was quick to throw shit at boog when boog took a swing for gabe. There was a vote too.

Once monkey has posted, I think we can clear drew/monkey outright.

[BankItDrew]

So if we lynch boog, the only wolf team that can win is gabe/luco/rilla/rascal?

[BankItDrew]

So if we lynch boog, the only wolf team that can win is gabe/luco/rilla/rascal?

This was a response to post 1092

[BankItDrew]

I'd be sick to my stomach if ong turns out to be a wolf.

[OngBonga]

Also, considering my relentless assault on gabe, I think me and aubrey are now fairly in confirmed villager camp.

If I'm wolf with anyone else, I can win without any more effort, just waiting. And it's past 2am here, I could pretend to be in bed if I wanted to. No need for me to do anything.

If anyone thinks I'm wolf with gabe, then I'll have some of what you're smoking please.

[OngBonga]

I'd be sick to my stomach if ong turns out to be a wolf.

Don't worry, you won't need a sick bucket near you.

[BankItDrew]

Ong villager tell: ong is condescending

[OngBonga]

So if we lynch boog, the only wolf team that can win is gabe/luco/rilla/rascal?

This seems like the case.

[BankItDrew]

What % of keiths absence is role related? >0%?

[OngBonga]

Yeah I'm not giving that any thought at all, it's unproductive.

[BankItDrew]

Fair enough.

[aubreymcfate]

I've been suspicious of boog all game

lynch boog

but then rilla basically takes Day 1 off, then is trusting a player that hasn't been here all game.

rescind

lynch rilla

lol honestly this is almost enough to make me flat-out believe BiD is a wolf with boog. this came right after rilla bolded boog, btw.

I just carefully reread about 80% of this thread. Boog is wolfy as F. During the alleged crossclaim (which I believe is genuine), Boog seemed to be the one most aggressively (dare I say opportunistically?) taking the bait, even after gator revealed the truth. I've taken notes on specific posts by Boog that contain wolfy nuances, but I don't feel that's necessary to share at this point. The majority of us are members of the boog-is-wolfy choir, yeah? I'd divulge them on request though.

The wolves must be doing something somewhat fancy and counterintuitive -- this format demands it. However I keep trying to read the thread, especially the last few pages, with the assumption that boog and gabe are both wolves, and I find it difficult to believe. I don't see what they gain in barrelling each other down relentlessly. Right now, between Boog and Gabe, I think the best vote is Boog.

[aubreymcfate]

lynch boog

[BooG690]

And that's game.

[BooG690]

Aubrey, can I at least ask you to rescind your vote until Ong wakes up?

[BooG690]

It's the middle of the night and luckily Rascal+Gabe are probably sleeping.

Please rescind and use up the time we have.

[aubreymcfate]

Omg I didn't mean nor want to do that I actually thought about that before doing it too but im retarded and forgot that 2 dead villagers means majority is lessened.

yes rescind boog

but i still think we should lynch him lol

[BooG690]

Drew, the same applies for you. Without a rescind, we lose when Gabe+Rascal wake up. A middle of the night lynch is no good, especially when Ong is sleeping.

[BooG690]

Omg I didn't mean nor want to do that I actually thought about that before doing it too but im retarded and forgot that 2 dead villagers means majority is lessened.

yes rescind boog

but i still think we should lynch him lol

Thank you Aubrey.

[BooG690]

I'm going to sleep. I think we have >50 hours left to go though I'm sure the game will finish IRL today (EST). Let's discuss this then. Night.

[Luco]

Gabe where are you? Get out of your cheeba coma and come vote boog with me

[Hoopy]

VOTE COUNT

Gabe (3): Boog, Hoopy, Ong
Boog (3): Luco, Rilla, BID

~66 hrs left

6 for a majority.

Not voting - aubrey, gabe, SMF, rascal.

We're lucky that the wolves weren't able to finish it off when aubrey voted boog.

[Hoopy]

2 wolves sitting on BooG, they just need one villager mistake and it's over.

Notice how BID has consistently avoided voting for gabe in the clutch.

gabe/luco/BID/SMF all day along.

[BankItDrew]

rescind

[BankItDrew]

2 wolves sitting on BooG, they just need one villager mistake and it's over.

Notice how BID has consistently avoided voting for gabe in the clutch.

gabe/luco/BID/SMF all day along.

Where is your God now?!

Also, if I'm a wolf with gabe, that means there are at least a cliple of villagers who are not voting for gabe 'in the clutch'. Has it occurred to you that maybe he doesn't appear wolfy to 100% of the village?

gabe went on a cheeba chew tangent when he bolded me then rescinded shortly thereafter. Other than that, I've agreed with just about everything he's said during these two gameday days.

[Luco]

Notice how BID has consistently avoided voting for gabe in the clutch.

But the reverse doesn't hold true, both gabe and I have been after bid/smf and I think we were the first people to call them out as wolves

Both bid and SMF are hard defending us now, but it isn't going to work as it's not a two way street. I think just straight attacking us would have been more +ev

[Hoopy]

But the reverse doesn't hold true, both gabe and I have been after bid/smf and I think we were the first people to call them out as wolves

Both bid and SMF are hard defending us now, but it isn't going to work as it's not a two way street. I think just straight attacking us would have been more +ev

How about you vote for them then?

[lilrascal]

I'm sorry that I wasn't around yesterday. I worked late then went to my bowling league.

I haven't had a chance to catch up, but I'll do that this evening.

[BooG690]

A villager vote on gabe would pretty much prove he's a wolf, btw. It'd be nice if SMF would pretend to care.

[gabe]

from my POV, BID is the clear vote here. wtf is this post...

I've been suspicious of boog all game

lynch boog

but then rilla basically takes Day 1 off, then is trusting a player that hasn't been here all game.

rescind

lynch rilla

look at his recent voting record. he can't be doing this as a villager. he's smarter than he lets on sometimes

he is a better vote than boog because of the possibility of rilla/rascal/bid/smf. i dont think RR/BH is possible anymore after rilla votes boog. however BID can be on a team with rilla and vote for him because theres no risk

i know ong thinks RR/DM is not possible because they could have hammered me early d2 for the win when boog and hoopy both voted for me. this is true.. if smf was active. if he's not, it ends up looking very bad for rascal to stay on me, so he rescinded (this is what ong pointed out on page 10)

rilla has sounded good on tone since his return but i agree with boog that he has made some lazy posts like this one

Have to keep your thoughts away from the wolves, too. I put a lot of info into those posts where I called out complete wolf teams. For one, I anonymized to protect villager pairs. You might not appreciate it, but when pairs of players were unknown that was a good time to see who keeping tight-lipped about who they found wolfy/villagery. What a mess you'd find yourself in if you barrel down aubrey and hard-clear ong only to find out they're buddied.

Strange gabe couldn't understand that and Boog couldn't respond to my direct call-out of him. Nor did gabe. Nor did Keith. Hoopy did though.

on post #8 in the thread, i said we should wait until the end of day 1 to out. i only started arguing for it to happen once the thread was stagnant. i am sure discussion was stalling out because i was in the thread often and we couldnt get people posting. also ong saying we should wait until day 2 made me feel like i really needed to argue the point of outing day 1


BID has been wolfy. it would be fishy to eliminate team RR. BID must be on the wolf team, whether with boog/hoopy or rilla/rascal. therefore we need to vote for BID

lynch BID

holla if you agree

[BooG690]

holla

[BankItDrew]

lynch gabe

Okay, I'm officially not keeping gabe in my village camp.

I'm now pleading with other villagers to help out here.

I'm 80%+ confident the wolves are gabe/luco/hoopy/boog

[BooG690]

lynch gabe

Okay, I'm officially not keeping gabe in my village camp.

I'm now pleading with other villagers to help out here.

I'm 80%+ confident the wolves are gabe/luco/hoopy/boog

Just saying, if Hoopy and I were wolves with gabe, this is about the part where we start making up excuses to rescind.