Quote Originally Posted by NightGizmo View Post
What do we want to accomplish this mission? Obviously our goal is either (a) get all rebels (win a mission) or (b) get a lot of spies (to help separate the spies from the rebels). The problem with (b) is that some spies could vote for the mission to succeed, so we still wouldn't really know how many spies are in the group (and we'll have to win the next 3 missions in a row to win the game). But the problem with (a) is that we have such a slim chance of getting it right.

I think we should try to get all rebels. If we manage to hit all rebels, obviously we win because we can just keep picking the same group. And if we end up with spies, then we'll be in the same position as option (b). So I don't see a big advantage to trying to get a large group of spies together for a mission.
So basically, to win its like this

A) We pick all rebels.
--This seems fairly unlikely. All it takes is one slipup and we fail this option. The funny thing is that each successful rebel pick increases the likelihood of the next pick being a spy, so we could be good enough to get 3 rebels but then not be able to beat likelihood of the 4th being a spy.

B) We pick many spies, they double+ vote failure
--It seems more likely that we can pick the spies, but it may be too easy to tell each other how to vote.

C) We pick many spies, they all vote succeed
--This means we have to have more than 1 spy, and they have to level themselves. I think this is less likely to happen than B), but more likely than A).

On the other hand, im personally confident we can pick 4 rebels. I see it like this

JKDS-obv rebel
Boog-rebel
lolz-rebel
JV-rebel

rilla-spy:
ong-spy:
wuf-spy:

Dan-? leaning towards rebel
Gizmo-? leaning towards spy
BID-? leaning towards rebel, but hes saying jack this game

The problem is that 1 mistake is all it takes to fail the mission, and a single failure vote is poor information. Im down to try the current group and hoping for a double or triple failure, but im also willing to give JV a shot at picking 4 rebels (himself included). Im not sure enough on gizmo to let him choose