*** Super Meta Werewolf Gameplay Thread ***

[DropTheBanana]

If he's not going to show up, it's better that we lynch him than let wuf modkill him. Plus I think jyms is right -- he's just trying to post-count his way into qualified status without actually contributing, which is pretty lynch-worthy by itself.

rescind jkds, lynch spidey

Modkill plus a lynch gives us a 1:10 chance of hitting instead of a 1:20.

We're in no worse shape info wise if their both villagers.

Depends how aggressively and/or frequently Wuf modkills.

[jyms]

Modkill plus a lynch gives us a 1:10 chance of hitting instead of a 1:20.

We're in no worse shape info wise if their both villagers.

Depends how aggressively and/or frequently Wuf modkills.

It could also take out 3 villagers after night one if we take out two villagers

[DropTheBanana]

It could also take out 3 villagers after night one if we take out two villagers

I can't disagree, because that's a fact.

Thinking on a more macro level, we don't lose that much value later in the game since there is no vigilante who exposes us to losing 3 villagers every other night.

[NightGizmo]

Thinking on a more macro level, we don't lose that much value later in the game since there is no vigilante who exposes us to losing 3 villagers every other night.

Just because we don't run the risk later in the game from a special doesn't mean that it's fine to run that risk on Day 1 due to a modkill. You claim "we don't lose that much value later in the game," but the fact is we do lose value by choosing to let spidey get modkilled.

Bottom line -- increasing the body count early in the game hurts the village in the long run. The more villagers we have around, the longer the village can hold out against the wolves and the more information we get to find/lynch the wolves.