Quote Originally Posted by wufwugy View Post
This is what aesthetics is. On the list of pros and cons, you have one pro for JS and a million cons, while a million pros for AD and just a couple cons. The fact that JS appeals better in some instances or to some people still doesn't make it a wash in comparison to AD. Within our groundwork assumptions of what the study of aesthetics is, we can most assuredly say that AD mops the floor with JS.
But we're talking about whether or not aesthetics are subjective. If you are an idiot with a short attention span, then JS is unequivocally better than AD. If you are smart, then it is the other way around. The value of the two shows is subject-dependent. The aesthetic valuation of the two can be said to be subjective.