Congratulations to the Ultimate Villagers

[baudib]

speaking of Gabe how come you guys didn't listen to him?

I'm going to start a new club: VWTLTG - Villagers Willing to Listen to Gabe

[wufwugy]

speaking of Gabe how come you guys didn't listen to him?

I'm going to start a new club: VWTLTG - Villagers Willing to Listen to Gabe

I realized we had to get around to it instead of address immediately. Also you definitely swayed the narrative at many times. Gator slumped into a hole where he was either a busy villager or a discouraged wolf. I was waiting for more information to see which one it was

Honestly I thought he was the cursed because he seemed so discouraged and wishy washy on his reads, which is one of the main ways the cursed naturally plays. After the Keith lynch, we were going in a different direction so I slept on that info

But yeah, I told Gabe he gets mad cred for this if he's right, so GABE GETTIN DAT MAD CRED

It's now between Gabe and JKDS for the best natural soulreaders

Oh btw JKDS, I remember how you said if only in the last game you have somebody who would listen to ya. High five

[JKDS]

Daven was amazingly wolfy there's no denying that.

But if Gabe flipped seer I think you would have had to assume Daven was his peek.

I dont remember enough about day 1-2. They blur together. Im sure that if it seemed like gabe cleared daven with his day2 posts, then yes. But if it seems like he still had a hard on for monster, then no.

speaking of Gabe how come you guys didn't listen to him?

I'm going to start a new club: VWTLTG - Villagers Willing to Listen to Gabe

On the same token, why didnt we listen to Dhuber? Dhuber has been crushing these games, readwise. This is the second in a row (maybe more?) where he both sniffed out wolves, and villagers, when others couldnt.

But like dhuber, we cant assume that the reads of dead people are accurate. Sure, theyre lynched for a reason. But whats the reason? Did the wolves think dhuber was a seer because of he hinted at something in post xxx, or did they think he was a seer because he went after keith d3? Its impossible to tell, usually, why someone was nommed (wihtout den info). And given that we post villager and wolf reads, its hard to tell which side of that list mattered...if any of it did.

But really, it comes down to this. Whose reads are better, your current reads...or those of a deadman who relied on less information than you have. When the argument is just "ong thought jkds is a wolf", all I see is an ad hom fallacy, and I ignore it. When the argument is "dhuber thinks keith is a wolf for x, y, and z, and these are still valid points"...I can get behind that. I can use that to form my own opinion, one that meshes well with how I interpreted the game to be going.

If you dont buy that...then from here on out, whenever I say "Im using my one time, follow me and lynch x", i demand ppl listen