May 2015 Werewolf Gameplay Thread

[gabe]

why would you ponder if anyone is interested? havent in the past you just assumed people would find it useful, so you did it anyway? but now you are making a point to have everyone notice how you do this helpful village activity of posting graphs

lilrascal is legit wolfy already

[Luco]

why would you ponder if anyone is interested? havent in the past you just assumed people would find it useful, so you did it anyway? but now you are making a point to have everyone notice how you do this helpful village activity of posting graphs

lilrascal is legit wolfy already

I'm liking gabe for villager already. Rilla too. I'm unconcerned with rascals posts so far.

[baudib]

I'm liking gabe for villager already. Rilla too. I'm unconcerned with rascals posts so far.

I'm interested in why you think so since you're the GOAT Gabe reader.

[Luco]

I'm interested in why you think so since you're the GOAT Gabe reader.

I like the tone of that post, like 'legit wolfy' - it's not a phrase I'd expect from wolf gabe this early, regardless of rascal's alignment.

[baudib]

I like the tone of that post, like 'legit wolfy' - it's not a phrase I'd expect from wolf gabe this early, regardless of rascal's alignment.

eh

Gabe always finds Rascal wolfy, or perhaps more accurately, always goes after Rascal as a wolf. I'm not giving Gabe villa points so light.

He's also asked for angel protection as a wolf before.

[a500lbgorilla]

eh

Gabe always finds Rascal wolfy, or perhaps more accurately, always goes after Rascal as a wolf. I'm not giving Gabe villa points so light.

He's also asked for angel protection as a wolf before.

It's all infront of Gabe. He can play with asking for angels and he can play with going after Rascal.

[gabe]

eh

Gabe always finds Rascal wolfy, or perhaps more accurately, always goes after Rascal as a wolf. I'm not giving Gabe villa points so light.

He's also asked for angel protection as a wolf before.

re:rascal yea but 2 of last 3 games i didnt make a mistake going after rascal because i was a wolf. the other game, if i remember correct, i was going after rascal because the village was coming after me and i thought it would increase my survival. those games i had reasons to do it. here i just sensed him say something out of place and freely posted about it. its day 1... i have no motive


as for your 2nd point, anyone can ask for angel protection as a wolf. i did it here because in the moment of that post i was thinking it was an important thing to say. all my posts before this one i just said whatever the gamethread made me think. this post was different because i had a couple points and wanted to be clear, so i put some construction time into it. where the others i havent (because they are natural innocent villager posts)

[lilrascal]

re:rascal yea but 2 of last 3 games i didnt make a mistake going after rascal because i was a wolf. the other game, if i remember correct, i was going after rascal because the village was coming after me and i thought it would increase my survival. those games i had reasons to do it. here i just sensed him say something out of place and freely posted about it. its day 1... i have no motive


as for your 2nd point, anyone can ask for angel protection as a wolf. i did it here because in the moment of that post i was thinking it was an important thing to say. all my posts before this one i just said whatever the gamethread made me think. this post was different because i had a couple points and wanted to be clear, so i put some construction time into it. where the others i havent (because they are natural innocent villager posts)

Fair enough on your first paragraph, but I still don't get asking for the angel on the 22nd post of the game. It didn't appear to be in the flow of the game at all. You had no reason at that point to be worried about needing to be angeled.

So why ask? I'm legit interested.

[lilrascal]

eh

Gabe always finds Rascal wolfy, or perhaps more accurately, always goes after Rascal as a wolf. I'm not giving Gabe villa points so light.

He's also asked for angel protection as a wolf before.

Good point here by Baud. I didn't realize it until he pointed it out. Gabe does come after me every game. I'm guessing it's because he thinks I'm an easy mislynch.

Also, as I pointed out in my earlier post, I found it odd that Gabe's asking for angel protection this early. I can't think of a good reason for a villa to do that at this point in the game, but a wolf could be doing it to PR hunt.

[Luco]

Rongs reaction was great, try to imagine it from my seat. You were very quick off the mark gabe. Also,

I'm liking gabe for villager already. Rilla too. I'm unconcerned with rascals posts so far.

I posted this before reading my role pm, my read on you and Rilla wasn't fake

[lilrascal]

There's a bit of catching up for me to do today. I've skimmed the thread, but, I'll just start where I left off.

why would you ponder if anyone is interested? havent in the past you just assumed people would find it useful, so you did it anyway? but now you are making a point to have everyone notice how you do this helpful village activity of posting graphs

lilrascal is legit wolfy already

The reason that I asked if anyone was interested in the vote graphs is someone (I don't remember who and didn't go back to find it) gave grief to MMM for posting the vote graphs for EOD saying it was just busy work. I find them useful and I'm willing to share and since MMM isn't playing this game, I volunteer to step up and provide that info.

About my making a point of it: the ONLY other game that I've ever posted vote graphs is the Champions game on POG. I have done other charts here for my reads, but I've never posted those graphs before.

[JKDS]

The reason that I asked if anyone was interested in the vote graphs is someone (I don't remember who and didn't go back to find it) gave grief to MMM for posting the vote graphs for EOD saying it was just busy work.

It was meeeeee



I was right tho...

[lilrascal]

It was meeeeee



I was right tho...

I agree they aren't always helpful, but they can be in many situations.

I used them to reverse a villa read that I had on someone in a game and they proved out to be a wolf.

[JKDS]

I agree they aren't always helpful, but they can be in many situations.

I used them to reverse a villa read that I had on someone in a game and they proved out to be a wolf.

Thats the rub tho, isnt it?

Actions are not wolfy or villagery. Its the motivation behind them.

Also, gabe almost always asks for angel protection early. Idk why.

[lilrascal]

Thats the rub tho, isnt it?

Actions are not wolfy or villagery. Its the motivation behind them.

Also, gabe almost always asks for angel protection early. Idk why.

They're no help on D1, but after a lynch they can be helpful.

I didn't know that about Gabe. So, it's not role indicative.

[gabe]

i dont think rascal's defense of his original "hey want me to make charts?" post is good enough. in a vacuum, his original post is wolfy and he can't explain it away.

The reason that I asked if anyone was interested in the vote graphs is someone (I don't remember who and didn't go back to find it) gave grief to MMM for posting the vote graphs for EOD saying it was just busy work. I find them useful and I'm willing to share and since MMM isn't playing this game, I volunteer to step up and provide that info.

About my making a point of it: the ONLY other game that I've ever posted vote graphs is the Champions game on POG. I have done other charts here for my reads, but I've never posted those graphs before.

your first sentence doesnt make sense to me. you are basically saying, "i asked because someone did something to someone else while saying charts were busy work." what do you exactly mean here?

your second sentence is very clear and i agree

your 2nd paragraph can be ignored if you substitute my use of "charts" for "visual aids." you used them starting in your first game here when no one else was doing it. there were a few posts pointing it out (e.g. "i like this new guys color scheme!")

[lilrascal]

I'm heading out for some Memorial Day Festivities. I might possibly be back later this evening.

Since MMM isn't in this game, I'll post vote analysis posts if anyone is interested.

why would you ponder if anyone is interested? havent in the past you just assumed people would find it useful, so you did it anyway? but now you are making a point to have everyone notice how you do this helpful village activity of posting graphs

lilrascal is legit wolfy already

i dont think rascal's defense of his original "hey want me to make charts?" post is good enough. in a vacuum, his original post is wolfy and he can't explain it away.

your first sentence doesnt make sense to me. you are basically saying, "i asked because someone did something to someone else while saying charts were busy work." what do you exactly mean here?

your second sentence is very clear and i agree

your 2nd paragraph can be ignored if you substitute my use of "charts" for "visual aids." you used them starting in your first game here when no one else was doing it. there were a few posts pointing it out (e.g. "i like this new guys color scheme!")

Let's get the actual initial posts listed here, rather than you're inaccurate paraphrasing of me.

I made a simple statement as I was leaving for the day that you're making out to be something much bigger than it is.

You're really starting to ping my wolfdar pretty strong now.