Russians vs. Americans: A Werewolf Game for October 2015

[a500lbgorilla]

Rilla -- when I first read his two posts, I had a feeling that it was wolfy -- nothing concrete, but it just kind of felt wrong. When I last played, he started playing more quiet and cryptic as a villager so he could balance that against his wolf game, so I wasn't sure of my read. So I checked last game to see if he played. As Ong pointed out, he was fairly active and did a strong job of pushing the village on D1 (as a villager). So that info strengthens my thoughts on Rilla.

Kami -- she hasn't bothered to defend herself, and based on her current posts and what I read from last game, even if she does pop in it will just be to insult anyone that bolded her and spew out nonsense. Wolfy? No clue. Liability to the village? Certainly.

Luco -- I read through his posts again, aside from calling me out for something that he later said himself, nothing concrete.

Ong -- I like his analysis and logic, although I'm not sold on the drew thing, mainly because I remember drew as being very unpredictable. Seems villagery.

Tom -- he's active, his conversation has a lot of content -- he seems the most likely to be a villager.

We still have a lot of inactives and there are bound to be some wolves in that group. The hardest thing about being a wolf is typing up content.

Take a slice at wuf, gabe

[NightGizmo]

Take a slice at wuf, gabe

Gabe -- I'm used to Gabe posting a lot more, so I'm surprised he's been so quiet. I'm not thrilled by his poisoner questions -- seems like an odd suggestion, to have the village poisoner try to match the wolf -- I'm not sure how the village poisoner is supposed to know what the wolf poisoner is going to do. Leaning on the wolfy side, but it's not a very strong read. IIRC Gabe tends to throw out any idea that pops into his head, and they are often pretty out there. I'll be more concerned if he continues to stay quiet.

Wuf -- also really quiet. I don't like how he offered himself up for a cfd, but frankly there just isn't anything in his 5 posts that triggered anything to me. He was the first to point out that we shouldn't vote for bigred because of the sub, so I'm neutral on him.

[a500lbgorilla]

Gabe -- I'm used to Gabe posting a lot more, so I'm surprised he's been so quiet. I'm not thrilled by his poisoner questions -- seems like an odd suggestion, to have the village poisoner try to match the wolf -- I'm not sure how the village poisoner is supposed to know what the wolf poisoner is going to do. Leaning on the wolfy side, but it's not a very strong read. IIRC Gabe tends to throw out any idea that pops into his head, and they are often pretty out there. I'll be more concerned if he continues to stay quiet.

On top of his out there ideas, he also pitches cryptic reads that are difficult to puzzle out - none so far.

[NightGizmo]

On top of his out there ideas, he also pitches cryptic reads that are difficult to puzzle out - none so far.

You asked for my thoughts on Gabe, I gave you the few I had. And I don't have any real "reads" -- it's just my gut on the little information available. Which I freely admit is very thin, considering my baseline opinion of him is from quite a while ago.

Frankly, I feel a lot more confident that you're a wolf after your last few posts, and going for a wolf > eliminating a useless player. lynch rilla

[a500lbgorilla]

Frankly, I feel a lot more confident that you're a wolf after your last few posts, and going for a wolf > eliminating a useless player. lynch rilla

What did you think I was posting?

[Luco]

You asked for my thoughts on Gabe, I gave you the few I had. And I don't have any real "reads" -- it's just my gut on the little information available. Which I freely admit is very thin, considering my baseline opinion of him is from quite a while ago.

Frankly, I feel a lot more confident that you're a wolf after your last few posts, and going for a wolf > eliminating a useless player. lynch rilla

This kneejerk vote has a villagery feel to it

[NightGizmo]

On top of his out there ideas....

Also, what "out there ideas" have I had? That without reads it's a good idea to eliminate a player known to provide no value to the village?

[a500lbgorilla]

Also, what "out there ideas" have I had? That without reads it's a good idea to eliminate a player known to provide no value to the village?

I was talking about gabe. I was agreeing with you post and adding on another bit of gabe that's been missing.

[NightGizmo]

I was talking about gabe. I was agreeing with you post and adding on another bit of gabe that's been missing.

Lol, oops. I thought you were saying that I had out there ideas and a cryptic read on Gabe. That changes things... Sorry about that.

kami