Sep 2015 Werewolf - Game thread

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Cory

I believe in compromise, plus nobody else would vote him for whatever reason

Good playing with you dad :)

---

:thumbsup:

You should play here more often. The pace is a bit more relaxed, which fits my schedule more and sounds like it would fit yours too.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Kami

I literally had no way of knowing self voting was against the rules btw

`-`

---

This is why I think it's bad to modill players for it. The modkill precedent was set long ago, so people here see it as almost as hard rule. But actually I don't see what the problem is with it, because if someone merely expects to gain one vote for it, then it's not particularly alignment indicative. if it is alignment indicative, ie "I only self vote as villager", then it's a truth tell, which is a modkill. But the self vote thing, we're stricter than we should be imo.

I'm glad this was dealt with leniently. Even as wolf I would not want to see a modkill for that, so my plea for leniency was also non alignment indicative! No truth tells here either!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by lilrascal

I can't believe you'll lynched my peek over BID. :(

---

I can't believe you claimed.

I can't believe you didn't get roleblocked.

I can't believe we won so quickly.

MVP is either myself or rilla, with me edging it of course.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

This is why I think it's bad to modill players for it. The modkill precedent was set long ago, so people here see it as almost as hard rule. But actually I don't see what the problem is with it, because if someone merely expects to gain one vote for it, then it's not particularly alignment indicative. if it is alignment indicative, ie "I only self vote as villager", then it's a truth tell, which is a modkill. But the self vote thing, we're stricter than we should be imo.

I'm glad this was dealt with leniently. Even as wolf I would not want to see a modkill for that, so my plea for leniency was also non alignment indicative! No truth tells here either!

---

On a personal level I think self voting is shitty anyway (it is pretty much de facto playing against your wincon) and I'm 100% happy to see it banned on FTR. However at the time of writing the OP I forgot to include it and that was my mistake, not kami's.

I think the biggest impact that Kami self-voting had is that Evene was online while the thread was closed, so she might have been able to post and do something in that time to keep herself from getting shot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OngBonga

I can't believe you claimed.

I can't believe you didn't get roleblocked.

I can't believe we won so quickly.

MVP is either myself or rilla, with me edging it of course.

---

You need to become a believer. Without my claim, I get mislynched instead of us lynching wolf Hoopy D1 and this becomes a very different game.

Rilla obv MVP with his 2 kills.

I agree that on this occasion your claim worked out for the better, but that's being results orientated. Claiming when there's a roleblocker is not only bad, but wolfy; it's not crazy for me to auto assume that you're a wolf who didn't think the claim through properly, rather than a seer.

I hope you don't take offence to my comments about how your claim was stupid. It's just my opinion, and I have plenty of stupid moments myself.

And yes I know rilla MVP'd this, it's not remotely close. I'm just massaging my ego even though I sucked this game.

Rilla's not the MVP. most vigs shoot at least 1 wolf in 2 nights in this game.

In a vacuum D1 seer claims are very bad.

To everyone that sent me their wolf picks at night - you were all wrong

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Luco

To everyone that sent me their wolf picks at night - you were all wrong

---

Someone in the game mentioned there should be two main wagons, with the vig killing the surviving one.