Russians vs. Americans: A Werewolf Game for October 2015

[Top Tier Tom]

hey all.

Just read through everything, here's some initial thoughts:

* Regarding those who bolded/targeted Kami: Day 1 person posting flippantly is definitely going to attract at least one wolf in the group of people targeting her.

Top Tier Tom, Ong, and Wug found her wolfy bc of that initial bold and poor reasoning. Gizmo and BID seemed less convinced that she did anything wolfy, and just found her a worthy d1 lynch bc they didn't find her posts serious enough. So there are 2 camps of Kami lynching -- those who took her posting seriously enough to think she is wolfy, and those who see that she's posting like she doesn't care and find her a liability.

conclusions from above: There is definitely a wolf in that group, even if I don't find voting for her particularly wolfy in and of itself (majority of kami votes are villagers, obv). Not sure if one mode of reasoning seems wolfier than the other yet but I think it's worth keeping in mind.

* Gizmo flipping to Rilla when he thought Rilla was wolfy and back to Kami when Rilla clarified his post makes Gizmo lean more villager than the rest to me. It looks authentic.

* chuckling IRL at the rocky convo. makes lilrascal lean village for me bc of how much of a stretch it is. seems more likely for a villager to try to catch someone on some insanely subtle slip (and be so earnestly relentless about it!) but if he is a wolf, that's very clever.

Why's there "definitely" a wolf in that group? Kami is definitely a villager, or you think there's a wolf regardless of her alignment? I don't see why that is definitely the case.

[aubreymcfate]

Why's there "definitely" a wolf in that group? Kami is definitely a villager, or you think there's a wolf regardless of her alignment? I don't see why that is definitely the case.

I feel pretty confident that Kami is a villager. It's a big part to do with her posting style, but that's not enough -- what really seals it for me is her "lynch me more" post. She doesn't have much experience and most people see her as a liability; if this something she was capable of as a wolf strategy, someone would have said it. She seems like mislynch bait to me, so that's the angle I'm basing the rest of my thought process on. I failed to get this across clearly in the original post bc I was catching up on a lot at once and refining my thoughts as I typed.

[gabe]

Why's there "definitely" a wolf in that group? Kami is definitely a villager, or you think there's a wolf regardless of her alignment? I don't see why that is definitely the case.

i agree with aubrey that there is very likely a wolf in that group. i could see why she thinks that. it just seems like out of all the wolves, at least one would get involved with all of that