Double Day Unlimited Werewolf

[gabe]

I mean I'm pretty much insulted that anyone would think I'd be stupid enough to not kill the best villagers but whatever.

yea but its probably a mistake to 100% always kill the best in spots like these. sometimes you gotta leave the best villagers alive, because they will surmise that you couldnt have the been the wolf (because like you said, you think its stupid, the best players will deduce you think its stupid, etc), then they can convince the rest of the village that its impossible for you to be a wolf!!

i love werewolf

[baudib]

yea but its probably a mistake to 100% always kill the best in spots like these. sometimes you gotta leave the best villagers alive, because they will surmise that you couldnt have the been the wolf (because like you said, you think its stupid, the best players will deduce you think its stupid, etc), then they can convince the rest of the village that its impossible for you to be a wolf!!

i love werewolf

one day we'll get to be wolves together and we can talk about this in depth but the nightkill is really the only part of the game that wolves control. you can't really control the lynches, you can't control what villagers will think about the nightkill. The time Ong nommed Luco in the ghost angel game is one of the rare times I've seen a FPS nom work out for the wolves.

there's just clear value in choosing to kill the best player, and no offense to Drew, who is a pretty decent villager when he's active and focused on the game, but even when he's ~ lock clear he's not going to be a good kill in this lineup.

This also, I think, points to Rascal, because JKDS pretty much knows this, I don't think Rascal realizes how tough it would be to get through an endgame with Gator and Gabe still alive.

[baudib]

yea but its probably a mistake to 100% always kill the best in spots like these. sometimes you gotta leave the best villagers alive, because they will surmise that you couldnt have the been the wolf (because like you said, you think its stupid, the best players will deduce you think its stupid, etc), then they can convince the rest of the village that its impossible for you to be a wolf!!

i love werewolf

BTW I was thinking about this and I'd say the correct analogy is raising with AA preflop. You can never be wrong by raising in any situation but occasionally there will be #raisins to not do it.